| Fall 2005 |
|
INFOLETTER
|
 |
 |
 |
Partner's Perspective |
|
Mergers & Acquisitions:
They're Not Just for Big Corporations
By Mark B. Bober, CPA/ABV, CVA
When most people hear the term "mergers & acquisitions," they think of huge
corporations and mega-mergers, like AOL-Time Warner, General Electric-NBC or
Bank of America-Fleet Boston.
But for every mega-merger that's on the front cover of the business
magazines, there are thousands of mergers and acquisitions of small and
mid-sized businesses just like yours. In 2004, there were 8,064 middle-market
M&A deals in the U.S. worth more than $152 billion combined, according to
FactSet Mergerstat, LLC.
So, does a merger or acquisition make sense for your company? Let's take a
look at this question from both sides of the table -the buying side and the
selling side.
Buying a Business: One Way to Grow
There are many different ways to grow your business, and one of them is to
buy another business. For most companies, there's a limit to how much they can
grow internally (or "organically") before adding more staff and other overhead.
Buying another business is an alternative to organic growth that may enable
you to add new and complementary products and services to your mix (i.e.,
vertical integration). Or maybe there's a competitor who's looking to sell, and
joining together offers more potential benefits to both of you than continuing
to operate independently.
The first question you should ask is a simple one: Why do you want to buy a
business? There may be many different reasons, but the final decision should be
the result of a strategic planning process and long-term vision for your
business.
Does an acquisition help you meet your strategic goals and objectives? Does
it strengthen your product line offerings? Does it give you deeper penetration
into your market? Does it help you better utilize assets that aren't delivering
an adequate return on equity? Will it increase your efficiencies, strengthen
your purchasing power or avoid duplication of costs?
On the other hand, can you meet your strategic and growth goals by some other
strategy? Could you put more money into research and development, or hire
additional salespeople? You must go through the discipline of answering these
and many other questions like them before embarking on a business acquisition.

Finding Acquisition Targets
If after working through these questions you decide that you do have valid
strategic reasons for buying another business, the next step is to begin the
process of searching for acquisition targets and performing due diligence on
them. Acquisition targets may be fairly limited and obvious if yours is a niche
industry or if your goals are narrowly defined. If not, a business broker can
help you identify possible targets.
In looking at potential companies to buy, remember that regardless of the
purchase price or past sales or earnings of the company, what you are really
buying is a future stream of earnings—or in other words, the ability of a
business to generate profits in the future. If a business isn't generating
enough earnings to provide an acceptable return on investment, and you're not
sure you can make that happen, then you should proceed with extreme caution.
Beyond the financials, you also need to consider the cultural issues involved
in an acquisition. Is the new business going to be culturally compatible with
your existing business? In recent years we've read about large corporate mergers
that made sense on the surface but broke down due to "softer" issues like
conflicting corporate cultures.
As you get deeper into your due diligence and negotiations with a potential
acquisition target, be careful to guard against "falling in love" with a
company. Remember: when push comes to shove, you don't have to buy the business
-you can always just walk away if you don't become too emotionally attached. The
acquisition will be rational and make financial sense or it won't, so be sure
you can tell the difference.
Selling Your Business: Steps to Take
Just like the decision of whether or not to buy another business, the
decision to sell your business must also stem from your strategic plan. Again,
you have to honestly assess why you want to sell your business: Are you ready to
retire? Do you want to start another business? Are you feeling burned out? If
so, maybe you just need a good vacation to help get some perspective on the
situation.
|
The Tax Impacts of Buying and Selling
From a tax standpoint, there are two main ways to buy and
sell a business: the purchase of stock and the purchase of assets. The tax
implications are different for each, with stock sales generally more
beneficial to sellers and asset sales generally more beneficial to buyers.
Buyers take on more risk and liability when they buy stock.
While tax implications are a critical aspect of any
business purchase, it’s important not to let the tax tail wag the dog. At
the end of the day, it’s the net economics of the deal for both the buyer
and seller that matter the most.
|
Assuming you're not selling to employees or family members, one of the most
important decisions you'll make in your preparations is your choice of an
investment banker. The investment banker will serve as the "quarterback" of your
team of experts and professionals who will guide you through the process of
selling your business&—a team that should also include an accountant and an
attorney who are experienced in mergers and acquisitions.
The investment banker's most important role is that of "market maker." He or
she will build a database of prospective buyers and then work to create interest
among the buyers and, ideally, an auction environment for the sale of your
business. The investment banker will also create a confidential memorandum that
presents your company to potential buyers and highlights the most salient
points.
A good investment banker will create a memorandum that attracts the right
kind of potential buyers and positions your company to sell at the highest
possible price. He or she will know what details to include and omit, what
features of your business to highlight, what issues to address, and what
questions to answer in the memorandum. The investment banker can also help you
weed through the "tire-kickers" and focus on the best-qualified buyers for your
business.
Many sellers assume that if they're not selling their company in the public
markets via an initial public offering (or IPO), then they don't need an
investment banker. But this may be penny-wise and pound-foolish. The sale of
your business is probably the largest and most complicated transaction you'll
ever undertake, and so it's wise to bring as much experience as possible into
your corner.
For assistance in buying or selling a business, please call or email me at
markb@bobermarkey.com
or your partner/manager contact. We have experience in many aspects of
the M&A process. BMF&C
Word to the Wise: Beware of
"Friendly" Financial Advice
By James M. Bowen, CPA, MT,
Partner
|
Whatever financial input your friends
give you, don’t act on it until you’ve checked it out with your own
financial advisor. Even if you have the smartest, most successful friends on
the planet, their advice may not apply to your specific situation.
|
How
many times have you heard investment or tax advice from your
friends over a card game, at the gym or on the golf course?
Expense deductibility, automobile depreciation, charitable
contributions—everyone has an opinion.
Here's some professional advice for you: whatever financial input your
friends give you, don't act on it until you've checked it out with your own
financial advisor. Even if you have the smartest, most successful friends on the
planet, their advice may not apply to your specific situation.
People often try to help out by passing along what they believe to be
valuable money-making or money-saving tips. In reality, the advice may not apply
to you for a variety of reasons. Acting on such "friendly" advice can truly be
disastrous. Here are a few thoughts to ponder:
Costly to fix: Certain actions come with enormous tax consequences.
For example, giving family business stock to a minor or changing the status of
your corporate organization can have huge tax implications. If you make a
mistake in one of these areas, it can be very costly to undo. By talking to your
CPA before taking action, you can save a lot of money.
Impossible to fix: Setting up an irrevocable trust is indeed
irrevocable. Certain stock gifts to children or charities may be irretrievable.
By missing a tax code expense deadline, you're losing an opportunity forever. A
quick planning session could stop any of these actions before it's too late.
Nice idea, bad timing: Some advice isn't inherently wrong—it just
may not be smart to act on it yet. For example, because of tax implications on
gains, timing is very important when converting from a C corporation to an S
corporation. Or perhaps it would be smart to wait until a certain date to buy or
sell an asset.
Illegal or too risky? Tax laws change constantly and vary from state
to state. Depending on your corporate set-up and state regulations, acting on
your friend's advice might be downright illegal—or it just might not be smart
for your situation. It's hard to keep up with tax code. For example, corporate
boxes at sporting events used to be deductible, but in most cases, they're not
any longer. Some of your friends may pay their children a salary from the family
business, but it has to be reasonable compensation for whatever duties the child
is actually performing.
Ask before you act. A quick conversation with your tax professional can save
you a lot of headaches—and a lot of money. BMF&C
The Critical Importance of
Business Succession Planning
By Richard C. Fedorovich, CPA, Managing Partner
|
According to actuarial tables, in a
business with two partners both 35 years of age, there is a 47 percent
chance that one of them will die before age 65. For two partners both age
50, the probability drops only slightly to 40 percent.
|
Have
you given serious thought to what would happen to your business
if you were to suddenly and unexpectedly die or become disabled?
While thinking about your own mortality and the need for succession planning
may not be the most comfortable process, failing to deal with succession
planning can be disastrous for your company and its shareholders and employees.
Without proper advance planning, the business could quickly crumble under the
weight of estate taxes and battling between the competing interests of heirs and
surviving owners/shareholders.
"But that's pretty unlikely," many owners (especially younger owners) think
with regard to premature death or disability. Think again. According to
actuarial tables, in a business with two partners both 35 years of age, there is
a 47 percent chance that one of them will die before age 65. For two partners
both age 50, the probability drops only slightly to 40 percent.
Statistics like these point to the critical importance of business succession
planning for small and closely held business owners. With proper planning, you
can ensure the smooth transfer of your business either to your heirs or to the
remaining partners while minimizing estate taxes due upon death that can cripple
your business.
Ownership and Management Succession Planning
Ideally, succession planning is divided into two main categories: ownership
succession and management succession.
- Ownership succession—Since the primary value in most small businesses is
in their relationships, there must be a structured plan for transitioning
those relationships to the successor owners. This isn't something that happens
overnight, so planning for ownership succession ideally should start at least
three or four years before the owner plans to leave the business.
- Management succession—The key to successful management succession is to
build a strong successor management team well in advance of your planned (or,
in too many cases, unplanned) departure from the company. If yours is a family
business, you must objectively determine whether or not your heirs are being
adequately prepared to lead the company after you're gone, or if they even
want this responsibility.
Questions to Consider
Here are a few questions to consider as you begin thinking about formalizing
your succession plan:
- Have you defined and articulated to others your personal goals and vision
for the transfer of ownership and management of the business? Ideally, your
goals and vision should be communicated clearly and unambiguously in a formal
written business succession plan that addresses both management and ownership
succession.
- Is your successor identified and ready? This may seem like an obvious
step, but it's one that's often overlooked. Many companies have only an
interim succession plan prepared for dealing with the sudden death or
disability of top leadership.
- Is there a buy/sell agreement in place? A buy/sell agreement is an
essential part of ownership succession planning for closely held companies. It
creates an immediate market by which any owner's interest can be translated
into cash through the buyout of that partner's shares by the other partner(s).
There is usually a valuation formula tied to the agreement that creates the
immediate market.
- Are you dependent on the business for retirement cash flow? For most
owners of family and closely held businesses, the sale of the business
represents their primary source of retirement income. It is essential that you
work together closely with estate and personal financial planning experts who
can help you plan the financial side of succession so that it provides a
comfortable stream of income to support your desired lifestyle during
retirement.
When done properly, succession planning may take months, if not years, to
develop and implement. This process is crucial, however, to helping ensure that
the years of hard work you've put into building your business are not wasted.
For assistance in succession planning, please call or email me at
rickf@bobermarkey.com.
We can provide objective advice and perspective to help you think through
the many issues involved with forming your succession plan. BMF&C
 |
In this feature of InfoLetter, each quarter we provide a profile of
one of our professionals who is available to work with our clients and
friends.
Danielle J.
Kimmell
CPA, Senior Manager—Assurance & Advisory Department |
Danielle recently joined Bober, Markey, Fedorovich & Company as a senior
manager in the Assurance & Advisory department. Danielle has nearly ten years of
experience, including several years with a regional accounting firm.
Danielle is focused on serving large, middle market privately held companies
in a variety of industries, including manufacturing and distribution companies.
She also has significant experience in the area of Employee Benefits Plans, as
well as issues arising in small business settings, including audit, compliance
and tax issues. Danielle, an Akron resident, holds a Bachelor of Science Degree
in Accounting from The University of Akron.
Danielle has served as a speaker for the accounting departments at The
University of Akron, Kent State University, and Mount Union both in the
classroom and for student organizations on technical accounting topics as well
as discussing careers in accounting with students.
Danielle is a member of the American Institute of Certified Public
Accountants, the Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants, Association of
Fraud Examiners, Young Professionals of Akron, and is Treasurer of Project GRAD
Akron (Graduation Really Achieves Dreams).
"BMF&C is committed to quality, both in the compliance work that is performed
and in our value-added advisory services. This commitment starts with the
Partner group and extends all the way to the administrative staff. This is
evident in the positive results received from external inspections and the
relationships that have developed as trusted advisors for our clients." BMF&C
|